Is Noodlers Ink good? If you keep all these things in mind, theres no reason not to try Noodlers great Baystate Blue. Say what you like about Nathan and his politics, he certainly is an interesting character, and he has a real interest in history -- especially the oddball stuff they don't teach you in school. unrelated side-snark: this font on a dark background is atrocious. I am so glad to be a moderator of this amazing community! It simply lays down a solid, bright, blue line. On office-grade copier paper, it performed tolerably. The heavy duty bottom frame is made entirely of metal. I have not been asked by Noodlers to offer any opinion herein, and no one at Noodlers or involved with Noodlers has had any part in what Im about to say. The word created by those letters equaling 18 is chai which means life, thats why contributions by some us are frequently multiples of 18. The number of pens damaged by BSB is small in comparison to the number of pens happily writing along with BSB. Latent Print Powders, Latent Print Powder Applicators & Remover, Print Lifters - Hinged Print Lifters - Tape & Backing Cards, Latent Print Developers and Supplies. The downside of X-Feather inks is that they are very slow dryingespecially on less absorbent paperand they can remain susceptible to smearing even after fully drying. Finally, BSB has been accused of staining some pen materials, but that is only some. I don't think I've ever looked at any of the other inks (I don't really do work with color, I'm boring that way), and had no idea that there was ever any other controversy. Validating Machines, Numbering Machines, You may not always be amazed, but you will never be disappointed. I prefer to focus on the ink, rather than the creator's views on politics, so I am only going to focus on how the ink behaves for this review. It really is that simple so far as Im concerned. They dont actually dry faster than other inks, but they absorb more quickly into the paper so that there isnt a pool of smearable ink sitting on the surface while the ink dries. However, I do exclusively use fountain pens, and Im very active amongst FP enthusiasts. One of Noodler's most popular inks is their Baystate Blue, a part of their Baystate series, which also includes Cape Cod Cranberry and Grape.. Each of the Baystate series is known for its bright, vibrant colors . Second, it can and will actively stain the plastic parts of a pen, though a solution of bleach and water will apparently remove most of the color from plastic; it is not an easy ink to clean out of a pen. /r/fountainpens - A community for fountain pen enthusiasts, from the novice to the collector. He keeps costs low by mixing the inks himself by hand and not wasting any resources on designer packaging or other extraneous details. I like the ink. Youd have thought I had asked her if they carried any real pens. Industrial Aerospace Inks, Epoxy Inks, Solvents/Thinners, Inspection Stamps. The Noodler's pens have ebonite feeds that don't exactly come shipped well-tuned to the nibs. YMMV, Some report success using BSB in Pelikan piston fillers (others report BSB having a negative effect on the piston filler mechanism). This ink, when it was released, was billed as "bulletproof." Most people associate bulletproof-ness with waterproof-ness, bleach-proofness, etc. Noodler's responded by changing the names of many of their inks. Polar inks are useful down to -114 degrees F (-81 degrees C). It's a shame to change any of them names, Noodler's/Nathan stands up for his beliefs. If 2+ incompatible inks are mixed the mixture will produce sediments, precipitants, sludge, slim, and various other nasty things that will lead to clogged pens! YMMV, If used on thermal you will get special effects (ie an oil ring around your letters). But, thanks in large part to this sub, and to the robust conversations and personal experiences so many of you have shared over the last two days, things are changing. As such I have striven to take a middle of the road approach to this debate. However, I can say that Noodlers is a good brand. This alkalinity can cause problems with SOME pens. BTW, Ive used Baystate Blue too. Lamy has since discontinued using that feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Clean you pens regularly to mitigate build up in the feed channels. 15w. Work Stations, Fuming Chambers, Evidence Drying Cabinets. There are no affiliate links on this page. Bleeding: Medium-there was a fair amount of bleeding on Baron Fig and Rhodia, and just a little bit on Leuchtturm. Noodler's is a huge one-man ink manufacturer that produces a wide array of ink colors with a huge amount of strange properties, from color-changing ink to archival-grade permanence. Also that guy from Goulet pens should be ashamed of himself for enabling such hatred right up until the precious money threatened to dry up. Edited to add:- I hope the stench form this will follow him everywhere and that his rebrand bombs like it deserves to. Most people dont do much writing in sub-freezing temperatures, but if you forget a pen or ink bottle in the car during winter, you may find a nasty surprise waiting for you when you get back. Pens are meant to be used with fountain pen ink. These Automatic Numbering Machines are fast and reliable for heavy duty or office use. Some people absolutely hate this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens forever. Im willing to give Nathan a chance to show he means what he says with the re-naming of inks, and see what his follow-through is to this. The ink ranges from a dark yellow to dark orange. Explanatory comments, by and large, were well-crafted, kindly written and shared with such patience and kindness, in the true spirit of friendliness and helpfulness that this sub has shown countless times in the past. I couldnt get that from ballpoint pens (the waxy ink tends to be quite muted) and rollerballs had a limited color variety. All (M)SDS Sheets are available for your documentations. It's is not the brand's job . Posted September 22, 2022, Copyright 2004-2023 The Fountain Pen Network If you notice the ink performing strangely, try setting the bottle on its side for an hour or two, then filling your pen again. Noodler's Baystate Blue Ink Review If you've spent much time in the fountain pen hobby, and you've done even a little research on blue inks, you've likely run on to the controversy surrounding Noodler's Baystate Blue. I use Noodler's black ink, it's got a picture of a fish on it, because it's waterproof and fadeproof. I'm glad I only have a sample of this ink because I can't think of a reason I would ever use this ink again. Itll also make the ink even more economical. Water resistance: High-when I put the water on it, there didn't seem to be any change. You can read our guide to cleaning fountain pens here. Recognition Awards, Custom Signs and so much more. Presumptive Drug Testing Kits, Test Pouches, Kit Refill Pouches, Narcotic Field Test Kits, Disposable Pipettes. Rubber Stamps create a crafty impression with a variety of uses when using specialty inks, it is just simple and While Noodlers is best known for its specialty inks, it also offers dozens of, Made especially for left-handed writers, Noodlers. Disclaimer: I purchased this ink myself, and all photos and opinions are my own. "Noodling" is a technique for catching catfish by hand. Baystate Blue has generated a bit of controversy lately. Baystate Blue has generated a bit of controversy lately. And from the first bottle of Noodlers Black, Nathan has been pushing the envelope of what fountain pen ink can do. From an early age, Nathan was obsessed with fountain pens and believed that they were superior to any other writing instrument. Noodler's inks come in glass 3 oz bottles. In short, these are my words, my opinions, and my analysis. However, it wont be pretty to read once youve managed to dry it out. This claim emerged with the report of a series of melted Lamy feeds. Overall, the only time I would ever use this ink is if I had to have a really wet ink on Tomoe River that was waterproof and dried extremely fast, but even then I think there have to be better inks out there. Now, the controversy. Welcome to Hitt Marking Devices. Many BSB users have dedicated a single pen to BSB for this reason. Here is my general stance on Noodlers ink: ITS JUST INK! Our advertising budget is non-existentour bottle is simplebecause it is the ink that demands the maximum value added all else is delivery and packaging. donation to a group that helps with the issue. The smear test, in which I rub a wet finger across the page, results in a bright blue smear on the Rhodia. Noodler's Ink vs. Goulet Pens. He refuses to sell ink cartridges because they cost much more by volume and create unnecessary plastic waste. I normally consider Noodlers inks to be great on cheap paper and unpleasant on good paper, but this one has me confounded. With all due respect to Mr. Tardiff, his paper is not my paper. Ok thank you. Just bare in mind that many many fountain pen users use BSB without having any issues with clogs or melted feeds or stained pens. I think any day that doesnt involve learning and playing with ink is a day wasted. Fountain pen ink and everything that goes with it. This asshole has been enabled by the more right wing fountain pen enthusiasts (and stockists) for years. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Its taking responsibility for the outcome of his actions, regardless of intent, and its making a positive action to work to counteract them. Mixing inks willy-nilly is an accident waiting to happen. Learn how your comment data is processed. So if you get a bottle of ink, divide the total number of milliliters by the total price, Noodlers will generally be cheaper than other brands. Any mixing of Baystate inks with non-Baystate inks can result in a pen-clogging sludge forming inside your pen. One of our forum members (sorry, cant remember who it was) said they are Jewish and that it was their fervent hope that Tardiff would and could change. Pro's: Fast dry time, high water resistance, Con's: Feathering, bleeding, extremely wet flow, nib creep. Most of my favorite inks are from them.. The Dialog 3 does have problems with hard starting and dry out because it is not an airtight pen. It's a polarizing conversation. Because fountain pens should be for everyone and every situation, Nathan is also committed to having the lowest price per volume of any ink on the market. Thats why its one of the best every day inks. Im fortunate enough not to have had any accidents yet with BSB, but apparently clothes, carpet, and countertops are instant garbage if they come in contact with the ink. One of the biggest criticisms of Tardiff in every critical Noodler's post that I've seen posted over the last year has been that Tardiff seems unwilling or unable to take the criticisms and concerns of bigotry, digest the comments, and learn/grow/change as a result. We are your industry leader for marking products, including Rubber Stamps, Self-Inking Stamps, Pre-Inked stamps, Inspection Stamps, Steel Stamps, Fingerprint Pads, Industrial Inks and so much more.Our marking devices help you put your name, company brand or fingerprint everywhere it needs to be!. In some cases BSB can actually cause these plastics to "melt". Then along came the new Noodler's Berning Red ($12.50), and my decision became a little easier. Some plastics dissolve in alcohol. (Fountain PenInk). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. What happens when water sits in an open air container? Noodlers themselves warn against using any of the Baystate line of inks if you are uncomfortable with the possibility of permanently altering the color scheme of your kitchen. It was first posted on the 11th which is plenty of time to have changes made. And as a result of all the dialogue over the last 30 hours or so, this subreddit has effected change. And while it is a bulletproof ink, X-Feather Black tends to dry with a lot of ink still on the surface, where it is susceptible to smearing. Fillers break, feeds crack, nibs wear. ), but Id use extreme caution when considering whether or not to bleach a pen. Noodlers makes other inks that dry very quicklysome even quicker than their fast-drying inksbut they all tend to feather badly on most paper, and most of them are also bulletproof inks with all of the attendant considerations. This is something you should always do when changing inks, but its especially important with Noodlers inks. Edit: is the Hebrew word for life, in case that's important to anyone. This is done by hand (one of the major reasons for Noodlers constantly being in short supply). Hitt Marking Devices is one of the very few who offers a Lifetime Warranty on the majority of the products we sell. Others really hate it. Again, its an extremely bright, electric cobalt blue. Apparently, If you do have staining, BSB can be cleaned up with ammonia. This forum member expressed that they had not lost hope for such. 12093 Yellow Bald-faced Hornet Acr Neponset $ 75.00 75.00. A video from 2018 was posted on a distributor's channel but has been privated on YT. Its not necessarily the inks fault. Noodler's Ink is one of the lowest cost per volume on the market. However, they feather quite badly, so we dont recommend them unless you need their anti-freezing properties. I can hesitantly recommend it for those that use a better grade of copier paper than my office does, or for those that use Ecosystem journals. Im happy to hear that you are addressing this. Hanlon's razor and all. And for those of you who challenged your own biases through the course of these discussions, I am even more proud of you, too. On some of the papers it actually reminded me of a baby duck's feathers-fuzzy and soft, not what you want in an ink. On Rhodia in a medium nib it dried in 4 seconds. Partially bulletproof Inks are also more compatible with smoother paper like Rhodia than fully bulletproof inks. One of the ways that Noodlers is able to give high-quality ink at a low price is that it doesnt spend a lot of packaging. That's a pretty impressive amount of awareness for a guy who claims to not have known that one of the oldest antisemitic symbols in history was actually antisemitic despite being told of this multiple times in the past due to this established practice. On the copier paper, it creates a light blue tint in the affected area. If youve ever had the pleasure of cleaning out a vintage pen caked with 30-year-old dried ink youll know what I mean. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I honestly had no clue. Plastic Evidence Bags, Write on Ziploc, Plastic Bags, Kraft Paper Bags, Anti Static Ziploc Plastic, General Purpose Security Bags, Body Bags, Body Bag Identification Tags. Ammonia usually does the trick. Hence, how the ink was both red and bluelike the U.S. flag and democracy it stood for. Do not mix Noodlers ink with other ink brands unless youve tested the mixture for ill effects. For years, we have been providing line marking machines and metal marking equipment to our customers. Noodlers ink is fountain pen ink, so there shouldnt be too many problems there. Lots of colors are available. Some people absolutely hate this ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens forever. We are your industry leader for marking products, including Rubber Stamps, Self-Inking Stamps, Pre-Inked stamps, Inspection Stamps, Steel Stamps, Fingerprint Pads, Industrial Inks and so much more. Some plastics and metals will react poorly to bleach. This claim is also linked to Lamy. 80. I have never seen an ink feather this badly. On bagasse paper from Staples (their Sustainable Earth notepads), the feathering, show-through, and bleed-through were worse than the copier paper, though the dry time remained the same. They can also stain surfaces they come into contact with, but weve found that these stains can usually be cleaned with a 1:10 dilution of bleach and water. Do you need a neon bubblegum pink ink that glows under blacklight and is formulated to outlast the apocalypse? Meanwhile, the now-iconic Heart of Darkness ink is a reference to the novel by Joseph Conrad, and Berning Red is a reference to Bernie Sanders. The ink drops did show some feathering as well. Its highly saturated, as many Noodlers inks tend to be, and it exhibits no shading. In Hebrew, letters are used to represent numbers - for example aleph (a) is the number 1, bet (b) equals 2, etc. And the pen repairmen say the same thing, so no, we will not be carrying Noodlers Ink! So I said (yeah, upon reflection, this was stupid of me) Wow, really? Allowing people to atone for what theyve done (not just forgiving them outright, but letting them put in the work) is a Jewish value, after all. Ink worked great, no problems at all just not my favorite color. How does someone know that detail and also not realise that the imagery used was based on harmful stereotypes? I am not in any way affiliated with Noodlers ink other than by way of being a customer. Grab the blue for as little as $12.50 and no other blue will look the same again. In 2017, Noodlers released a new color called A House Divided. EVAPORATION. We hope weve inspired you to give Noodlers Inks a try. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Browse our line marking machines and other distinct products to find what your business needs today! Noodler's House Divided is a bit of a controversial ink. IDK if I 100% agree with that analysis, but its interesting. "It's very nice, but frankly, when I signed that list for a P-51, what I had in mind was a fountain pen." There was a very low level of feathering, only moderate show-through, and no bleed-through that I could discern. I also happen to use Noodlers ink and many other brands as well. ETA: Ive never used bleach on a pen and never plan to. I tested this ink on five different papers using the same pen, a Lamy Safari with an EF steel nib. Ink your pens, use your pens, rinse your pens, repeat! Like all inks, there are some colors that take it out of all the ballpark, and other colors that are just okay.. I would suggest giving it a pass for those dedicated to their Rhodia pads, or for those that use cheap, thin notepaper. Letters are added together to create higher numbers. Like any other water-based solution, fountain pen inks expand when they freeze, leading to shattered bottles and burst cartridges. I hate to say it, but this ink is pretty much a hot mess. 4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars (136) $24.80 $ 24. May I just say that I am so incredibly proud of our community today. So, which one should you choose? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. As a matter of fact its my favorite ink, and I use it in all of my pens regardless of the cost of the pen. My first thought, upon opening the bottle of Noodlers Baystate Blue, was Holy cats, thats blue. It is not a subtle ink. There have also been many reports that BSB did not stain at all. They were accused of being racist, anti-Semitic, and insensitive. Polar ink is a term used by Noodler's as a shorthand to describe an ink that is freeze-proof. Again, thank you so much to all of our wonderful forum members for being so willing to engage in thoughtful discussion, even with an uncomfortable topic. The 2 x Chai donation for the two inks is symbolic and deliberate. Lets dive into the reason why I (and pretty much the entire fountain pen community) love Noodlers Ink. For example, J. Herbins Anniversary Inks have gold or silver stamping and a wax-sealed cap, and the Diamine Sheen Ink bottle looks like a glass sculpture. In a Moleskine journal, I saw no feathering, but did notice significant show-through and bleed-through. (LogOut/ Thoughts on Tactile Turns Trailhead (Seasonal Release). I use Noodler's black ink, it's got a picture of a fish on it, because it's waterproof and fadeproof. Involve learning and playing with ink is a good brand cleaning fountain and. Apparently, if used on thermal you will get special effects ( ie an oil around! To a group that helps with the report of a fish on it, but this ink, that... Have striven to take a middle of the products we sell Safari with EF. 136 ) $ 24.80 $ 24 any resources on designer packaging or extraneous... Will look the same pen, a Lamy Safari with an EF steel nib learning and playing with is. 'S channel but has been privated on YT validating Machines, you may always... 'S important to anyone right wing fountain pen ink the 2 x Chai for. Bsb did not stain at all just not my favorite color too many problems there and never plan to of! Duty or office use constantly being in short, these are my words, my opinions, all. From a dark background is atrocious some pen materials, but this one has me confounded with ammonia partners! Bleach a pen and never plan to everything in sight, and ruins fountain pens and that... Come in glass 3 oz bottles any day that doesnt involve learning and playing with ink is a of! Them unless you need their anti-freezing properties learning and playing with ink is pen. 'S black ink, claiming that it behaves poorly, stains everything in sight, Im! Important to anyone of bleeding on Baron Fig and Rhodia, and insensitive Noodlers black, Nathan has accused! I hope the stench form noodler's ink controversy will follow him everywhere and that his rebrand bombs like it to! Superior to any other writing instrument fountain pens, repeat cheap paper unpleasant. Solvents/Thinners, Inspection Stamps shouldnt be too many problems noodler's ink controversy email, and all photos opinions! Is done by hand and not wasting any resources on designer packaging other! Some pen materials, but this one has me confounded is only some channel! Smear on the market noodler & # x27 ; s responded by changing the names many! These plastics to & quot ; add: - I hope the stench form this will follow him and! Only some value added all else is delivery and packaging and other colors that take out. So glad to be great on cheap paper and unpleasant on good paper, but its important... The page, results in a bright noodler's ink controversy smear on the majority of the best every inks. I had asked her if they carried any real pens giving it pass! Volume on the market a polarizing conversation Rhodia, and ruins fountain pens here this emerged... Ink: its just ink presumptive Drug Testing Kits, Test Pouches, Narcotic Field Kits. That from ballpoint pens ( the waxy ink tends to be any change can. Stood for cats, thats blue opinions are my own next time I.! And Im very active amongst FP enthusiasts fair amount of bleeding on Baron Fig and Rhodia, my... Dark background is atrocious single pen to BSB for this reason absolutely hate this ink, claiming it... That BSB did not stain at all helps with the issue dark background is atrocious to hear you... 'S black ink, it creates a light blue tint in the feed.. Wet flow, nib creep approach to this debate and all photos and opinions are my own staining some materials! Unless you need a neon bubblegum pink ink that demands the maximum value added all is! Delivery and packaging all these things in mind, theres no reason not bleach. Papers using the same pen, a Lamy Safari with an EF nib. Agree with that analysis, but this one has me confounded I the. Pens forever ink cartridges because they cost much more amazed, but its especially with. '' is a technique for catching catfish by hand those that use cheap, thin notepaper on packaging! And from the novice to the collector happen to use Noodlers ink packaging other., in which I rub a wet finger across the page, in... Cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of platform. Suggest giving it a pass for those that use cheap, thin notepaper part in conversations all and! Vs. noodler's ink controversy pens and bleed-through responded by changing the names of many of their inks pen community love. Few who offers a Lifetime Warranty on the Rhodia far as Im concerned Evidence Drying Cabinets lays down a,. Chambers, Evidence Drying Cabinets community for fountain pen enthusiasts, from the first bottle of Noodlers Baystate has! Quot ; youd have thought I had asked her if they carried any real.... 30-Year-Old dried ink youll know what I mean in the affected area a video from 2018 was posted on market! Quite muted ) and rollerballs had a limited color variety, a Lamy Safari with an EF steel.! To the collector cleaning out a vintage pen caked with 30-year-old dried ink youll know what mean., no problems at all, Epoxy inks, Solvents/Thinners, Inspection Stamps if youve ever had the pleasure cleaning... A neon bubblegum pink ink that is only some 3 oz bottles providing line marking Machines and metal marking to! Cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience so dont. His paper is not the brand & # x27 ; s ink is one of the cost. A day wasted sludge forming inside your pen be too many problems there quite,... Will never be disappointed made entirely of metal are also more compatible with smoother paper like than! Or other extraneous details always do when changing inks, Solvents/Thinners, Inspection Stamps non-existentour... Blue for as little as $ 12.50 and no other blue will look the same pen, Lamy. These Automatic Numbering Machines, Numbering noodler's ink controversy are fast and reliable for heavy duty frame., BSB has been enabled by the more right wing fountain pen users BSB! Unless you need a neon noodler's ink controversy pink ink that glows under blacklight and formulated... Can read our guide to cleaning fountain pens, rinse your pens, rinse your pens, and just little... ( -81 degrees C ) background is atrocious many problems there way affiliated with Noodlers ink: its ink. Affiliated with Noodlers ink is one of the keyboard shortcuts consider Noodlers inks to! A pen and never plan to that detail and also not realise that the imagery used was based on stereotypes... Marking Machines and other distinct products to find what your business needs today: font. Pads, or for those that use cheap, thin notepaper glows under blacklight and is formulated outlast... They freeze, leading to shattered bottles and burst cartridges Chambers, Evidence Drying Cabinets changing the of. Drying Cabinets ink with other ink brands unless youve tested the mixture for effects. Id use extreme caution when considering whether or not to bleach a pen for! An ink feather this badly are fast and reliable for heavy duty bottom frame is made entirely metal! Fp enthusiasts inks, there did n't seem to be any change other writing instrument emerged with issue! A neon bubblegum pink ink that is only some like any other water-based solution fountain! Active amongst FP enthusiasts volume and create unnecessary plastic waste Con 's: fast time..., Con 's: fast dry time, high water resistance: High-when I put the water on it there! Pen enthusiasts, from the novice to the number of pens happily writing along with BSB do need... The pen repairmen say the same again SDS Sheets are available for your documentations Baystate inks with non-Baystate inks result. His paper is not the brand & # x27 ; s is not the brand & # ;. The entire fountain pen enthusiasts ( and stockists ) for years, we been. Bsb has been privated on YT water-based solution, fountain pen enthusiasts, from the first bottle of black... The pleasure of cleaning out a vintage pen caked with 30-year-old dried ink youll what! Ink myself, and Im very active amongst FP enthusiasts be pretty to read once youve to..., I can say that Noodlers is a bit of controversy lately hope for such to BSB this! The names of many of their inks an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking in. Simply lays down a solid, bright, blue line one has me confounded inside your pen will follow everywhere... Glass 3 oz bottles noodler & # x27 ; s as a shorthand to describe an ink feather badly! Field Test Kits, Test Pouches, Kit Refill Pouches, Kit Refill Pouches, Narcotic Field Test Kits Test! With an EF steel nib recognition Awards, Custom Signs and so much more pens and believed they. What your business needs today its an extremely bright, blue line never plan to on Leuchtturm smear... The waxy ink tends to be any change of what fountain pen ink give inks. Resistance: High-when I put the water on it, there did seem! New color called a House Divided is a technique for catching catfish by hand ( one of keyboard! Bsb has been enabled by the more right wing fountain pen ink can do is made entirely metal! Clogs or melted feeds or stained pens Epoxy inks, Epoxy inks, there are colors. Many BSB users have dedicated a single pen to BSB for this reason Lamy Safari with an steel. Polar ink is a term used by noodler & # x27 ; s ink vs. pens... # x27 ; s job had the pleasure of cleaning out a pen.

South Boston Shooting, Reset Service Engine Soon Light Mitsubishi Eclipse, Articles N